31 replies to this topic

[Dazz]

Just a small bit of feedback from the last 10 minutes I've been here;

Those rotating banners are so incredibly dumb.
There's so many Christmas banners that I feel like this place isn't active any more, because nobody has decided to remove those.

Additional, this isn't a stab at the artists, but some of the artwork isn't exactly... "great" - compared to the official artwork.

I'd suggest a single banner that fits the scheme of the site. Failing that, a few banners that aren't Christmas related...

Edited by Dazz, 08 June 2012 - 11:30 AM.

[novelty]

I think we should get to choose our banners and only cycle through when new banners are available.

I do like Kenneth's one though.

[Alexander]

I think the changing banners are awesome. Not only does it show off some great talent from users on this forum, but it also shows that there's an actual community here. Can't have a forum if you don't have people! And if you ask me, having one banner with official artwork we've seen 100 times would be boring! Diversity, please!

[MarcelloF]

The banners really should be updated, but I'd like them to stick with the fanart ones. Sure, some aren't as good as the official art, but so what? This is a fan forum, so I like their work being shown for it too.

[Blue Blood]

It's a community effort, and one of the rules for the banners if that you can't use official art for them. They have to be your own work that's submitted, which is not only nice for the artists but also the community feeling and originality. The idea is that they get updated regularly with new submission and festive themeing if there's anything going on. Admins have been too busy (or have forgotten, considering it's been so long) to update them. Yeah, I'm really sick of seeing so much Christmas stuff considering they've been up for over half a year now. If they don't have the time to stick with the rotating banners, then a solid one would be better.

Edited by Blue Blood, 08 June 2012 - 12:03 PM.

[Alexander]

Plus, having one solid banner with official artwork would mean Swiss' banner would be no more, and that's not a world I wanna live in.

I mean, really.

Spoiler

<3

Edited by Alexander the Swell, 08 June 2012 - 12:04 PM.

[Swiss]

I'll definitely agree that the Christmas ones need shot of. It's what, June now?

I'll also agree with everyone else and say that the community banners should really stay. They're so much fun! Plus I've got another one half-made that's similar to the one above.

[Dazz]

The more I think about it the more agree about community banners. It's actually pretty cool.

I think that the idea of selecting which banners show up is brilliant, that'd be really cool, but I doubt it'll be implemented.

I guess really this should just be whittled down to "Please get rid of the Christmas banners..."

[Abominal Taz]

The Christmas banners should be changed due to the fact that it's summer, but as for the community effort ones that aren't 'great', are creative, and I'm pretty sure they tried to technical limits. We could start working on SoS themed banners to replace Christmas ones.

[Cola]

Yeah, getting rid of the Christmas banners and putting a new set up is a common complaint.

I wonder what the holdup is?

[Gig]

If I remember correctly, Roarz was in charge of the banners. He would be the one to add new ones and stuff...

He mentioned sometime ago that he was swamped with real life and or personal things that prevented him from updating anything. It seems to still be true today, as you very rarely see him online.

I also have to mention that the banners aren't about talent. They're about the community, so some shouldn't be excluded just because others look better.

[Chris]

I'll look into getting them changed. Whether that means modifying the existing ones to remove the seasonal banners or hosting an event for more submissions, I cannot say.

[MarcelloF]

There's still submissions in the banner thread that haven't been used.

[Mono]

Yeah, we have to do some purging it seems.

[Discoid]

Yeah, there are still at least five banners in the banner submission thread that have been sitting there for months, if I remember correctly. Just replacing the Christmas ones with those would be cool.

[shimapun]

ITT Scrooges who do not wish to keep the spirit of Chirstmas alive all year.

[krisjj859]

Well Actually Roarz Clearly Stated that No Banners will be added Untill 25th Of Novembor So weve got a while to wait.
So That Means The Second Christmas Banners Go They Just Come Back...
What Give Roarz?

[Professor J]

I miss the days when we had different skins, it was such an exciting moment when a new one got revealed and it really let you personalize your... forum experience? lol.

Although I always stuck to the Sonical skin anyway, unless it was the amazing 2008 Halo'ween skin... haha!

[Mono]

Well Actually Roarz Clearly Stated that No Banners will be added Untill 25th Of Novembor So weve got a while to wait.
So That Means The Second Christmas Banners Go They Just Come Back...
What Give Roarz?

Where did he say that?

[Abominal Taz]

Where did he say that?

It should say in the banners topic in showcase, but I think that hasn't been updated since last year.