McGroose

True, some sometimes the AA can be so bad that it really should be turned off. Like with FF15 or something.

I don't really like either of them very much to be honest.

I like Act 2 of the PC version.

It's actually one of my favorite tracks out of the classic lineup but hey, I respect your opinion.

Never heard the PC version but I wouldn't be surprised if I would like it more

Me!

Unleashed Project doesn't count, I want everything from the Werehog to that annoying AF medal collecting

A PC port is like, the one thing I need from them at this point. After that... I won't even care what they do with the series. The perfect Sonic game would've already been made imo.

I mean, Unleashed is my favourite 3D Sonic game but I will goddamn roll out the red carpet for them cutting the annoying AF medal collecting in a re-release of the game.

If it were up to me, I would add additional ways to earn medals so gating progress allows the player to do a myriad of tasks to earn them based on their preferences (beating town missions, getting good ranks, etc), rebalance so day/night stages don't have their medals skewed one way or the other.  I'd prolly reduce the required medals for mandatory progress gates too, with more focus on medal-collecting being the way to unlock the extra acts.

Sonic Boom just due to 06 being fun to break.

Sonic 06 forever will be the worse for many reasons... even putting aside the awful gameplay! it has a ugly art style that doesn't match the series and a lame story that takes itself way to seriously.

@Lord-Dreamerz The notification sound from you posting that near gave me a heart attack.

Sonic Boom. For starters it’s part of an unnecessary sub-division in a franchise that was already divided by the million directions SEGA was taking their iconic character in. Don’t get me started about the hideous redesigns. The cartoon was the only good thing about the whole thing.

Only positive thing I can say about Sonic Boom was the character interaction. Very obvious issues aside, Sonic ‘06 gave me that as well as some really good music and some characters having good characterization. And even though it wasn’t its intention, it provided a significant amount of humor. Can’t say the same about Sonic Boom as majority of its glaring issues were not funny in the slightest. 

Gosh. They are both just so darn bad that it's hard to pick one.

Guess I'd pick Sonic Boom as the worst. It's soundtrack was pretty forgettable and it's boss battles were really dull. The level environments lacked variety and the replay value felt pointless. Sure, I could collect some stuff I missed...but why bother?

Also, what was Shadows deal, did Eggman even have a world conquering plan and why was Sticks an NPC that did nothing for the story, despite being shown as important to that specific branch of Sonic...ness?

Also the boring gameplay, automatic speed parts and the fact that it was glitch infested.

Boom, easily. I can actually have fun with Sonic '06. Fun for the wrong reasons, mind you, but fun all the same. It also has good music. Sonic Boom doesn't. 

Boom. 06 was an extremly watered down Adventure so had a bit of fun there, Shadow's story was kind of competent, Mephiles is a fun piece of ham fisted villain and it had a solid soundtrack. Boom had slowass gameplay that just feels bad, the worst writing the series has ever had, a boring villain and a boring soundtrack.