TheOcelot

Mania: 10

Project 2017: 8

Sonic Mania: 11

Sonic 2017: 3

Sonic Mania - 10

Sonic 2017 - 10 

Very hyped :D. 

Mania: 9

Sonic '17: 6

Mania, Strong 7 to light 8

2017: Light to decent 5

10's all round! Plenty to look forward to next year!

Same as you actually. Sonic Mania really impressed me right off the bat and I like Modern Sonic games more. Only reason why Project 2017 doesn't get a 10 from me but an 8 as I was very impressed with what I saw overall is because of Classic Sonic.

Sonic Mania: 10

2017: 4 (will probably go to 10 once the gameplay drops)

Initial Reaction to both games: jjlkjlgffjhjh

Sonic Mania is perfect just for the goodwill alone

Sega has told us almost literally nothing about '17 yet so I'm not really obliged to say much beyond that the teaser is fucking garbage.

5 both.

I don´t know, I'm not feeling anything.

Sonia Mania - 5

Sonic 2017 - 10

mania: 8

'17: 0

actually can i go negative on '17, I would like to go negative on '17

Mania: 3

2017: 7-8

Mania's not confirmed for NX yet so I'm not that psyched about it (as cool as it looks), and the 2017 game I need to see more. The teaser wasn't that exciting and Classic Sonic is a bit of a downer just because it feels like he's shoe-horned because "hey, people liked Gens and we can't avoid him, let's force him in despite Mania happening!" sort of thing. :/

The retro engine can run on a toaster, so as long as you have a computer you're already pretty much set.

Mania: 8. Looks damn fun, just waiting to see how the other characters are and how it weaves past levels in to boost it.

2017: 6. I loved Generations and thats what has given me the majority of hype. The other is we may get a bigger story this time. They just need to fill in a lot of details to raise the barrier.

Mania- 10

Sonic '17- 4

The teaser was rather worrying in terms of tone, and we also know jack about it. It also seems to be piggybacking of of a Generations, which may mean the return of the boost gameplay (which I don't think is flexible enough to be the main structure of games going forward). I'm also not big on Classic Sonic being present considering we're getting Mania :/

It's very possible the game will turn out fine, but from the teaser, it's not what I wanted.

Mania - 10

It's been ages since the last classic Sonic game came out and the Sega fan inside of me was happy. Classic old school gameplay with new touches, Sega references including really obscure stuff there. It's in good hands and know even at worst, it'll be a decent game and amazing at best. It also managed to make me smile and going to get it when it comes out (my first ever Steam game that I will buy).

Sonic 17 - 3-4 [at the moment, prove me wrong Sega]

I'm worried that it might be a Shadow/06 type of game with classic Sonic being in it as well. It's just a cutscene trailer so far but Sonic Team are hit or miss when it comes to games, especially if it is hinting towards the early 2000s again. So at the moment, very doubtful and only more footage with either ease the pain or my gut feeling is right.