Jump to content


TSS Member
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by calamityCons

  1. You can say that all you like, but sadly it legitimately is not that easy. Penders set a precedent to Sega of Japan with his antics, and he has left a mark on the Sega brand whether we like it or not. Many of the mandates are made in direct response to Penders’ lawsuit and the characters he wanted to keep. The no family members mandate, the no alternate outfits mandate, the no crying sonic mandate, etc. They are rightfully nervous and mistrusting of the writers for the american sonic comics specifically because of the years long legal battles Archie and Sega were forced to undergo. Basically, it is easier said than done because of this situation. It is not fair, and Sega SHOULD put more trust in the IDW creative team’s writing chops and characterization. But I honestly cannot blame them for being cautious about this, if I had a property that I loved, and someone from another country that doesn’t speak my language decides to work under me, create fan characters, and then sue for the rights to their fan characters, then demand royalties and mandatory consultation whenever I needed to use those fan characters? That’s only the basics of what Penders was demanding, and I still would find myself becoming more guarded and cautious about my property if i were in those shoes. It sucks and I hate it, but like. You can’t just undo that kind of impact yknow?
  2. Blame the pandemic, my friend. Schools, businesses, and everything else is also forced to deal with inconsistent schedules at this time.
  3. I agree that some more world building would be PHENOMENAL! But unfortunately it's unlikely to get into too much detail because the writers are so restricted to SEGA's vision of events and insisting upon Two Worlds, which makes things such as the Earthlike world map seen in Shadow the Hedgehog's cutscenes inapplicable, or the uniquely designed Unleashed world map. They have humans, which means they can't be used as a jumping off point. It's likely they'll have to come up with a completely new map from wholecloth, which would also lock Sonic's World into a canon which makes things even less contiguous and continuity a pain in the neck to keep track of. My favorite individual issues include issue 6 (Shadow vs Sonic and the moral question of Mr. Tinker), issue 8 (the introduction of Whisper the Wolf), issue 23 (Sonic confronts Eggman and Starline on their bullshit, nearly loses hope from the overwhelming guilt he feels for his decisions), and the 2020 Annual (Big's story and Metal Sonic's story are both the best damn things that could ever be told in limited page numbers, I'm SO DAMN IMPRESSED). I think the best character we've seen so far is Omega for his unyielding comedic sociopathy, Whisper for being allowed to show emotional turmoil in the face of such tragedy and maintain a sweet heart in spite of her strife, and Cream because that kid is AMAZING. I also really love Knuckles being a responsible and dutiful guardian, Tails doing everything he possibly can to help until he reaches his breaking point, Big for telling a silly, sweet, and tragic tale in the 2020 Annual, and god DAMN Team Chaotix is so lovable in this comic, I want to watch them bungle some mysteries and buy fancy take out.
  4. Do you guys think this topic deserves its own thread? I find this discussion about character design and market competitive edge in sonic fascinating and very engaging, but it isn’t really following this thread’s title anymore lol
  5. Sega of America with IDW are focused on making an engaging storyline that can whet the appetites of the fans who long for stories. Their primary focus as publishers and creators of a licensed comic book is to write a compelling tale that people enjoy. There are a lot of patterns being noticed here that I haven’t, and I appreciate that perspective. Personally I think the market has changed and that there is a point to be made about Rouge being “outdated.” She’s a femme fatale who uses sexuality as an angle toward getting what she wants, and in the nearly twenty years since her introduction a character like that could never really fit in with the child friendly comedy of the current Modern Sonic game canon. She CAN be portrayed comedically, but that isn’t what the fans are asking for. It’s lose-lose in a situation like this.
  6. Do you have any suggestions for how else that information could have been conveyed so as not to seem like a tacked on addition to you?
  7. My unpopular opinion is that Shadow the Hedgehog is a good game with a compelling story and unique progression system that I find very immersive and powerful.
  8. I really think y’all are splitting hairs here. The reasoning for Silver not doing this or that is because Silver’s character is naive and inexperienced, he doesn’t know what will happen in the future nor does he know for certain how time travel affects the future. If the characters all knew exactly how things will turn out the same way we the audience knows thanks to hindsight, then we will not get the kinds of action packed desperation fueled fight scenes and cool feats of superpowered heroism we achieve in comics like this. It is boring to have characters just know everything will be fine so they don’t bother going all out or trying anything and everything in hopes of succeeding.
  9. My money’s on Longclaw because my nostalgic memories of Sonic Underground would help me go bananas if Sonic’s vow of his mother being found were ever actually to come true. Sonic meets Longclaw again and I will vibrate into a parallel universe in glee.
  10. IDW Knuckles has been on Angel Island and dedicated to his duty guarding the Master Emerald since the end of the Neo Metal Sonic battle and did not appear again until issue 25 where he was still doing his job.
  11. If I were a writer for SEGA and I were incapable of portraying Shadow as anything more than a paper-thing jerkass idiot? I’d rather keep him in the background than wrestle with the license holders so that I could portray him as a rounded character.
  12. I definitely agree on Eggman valuing his own ego over sadism itself. There have been many times when he gets mad at things for being indiscriminately destructive yet his rampant pollution of the world through making his Eggman Empire/Eggmanland/Personal Theme Park causes just as much long term damage as, say, Dark Gaia or the Black Arms Invasion.
  13. I don’t think i’m one to judge people for their reactions to mandates because I’m very negatively affected by Shadow never having any other chances to show his caring and thoughtful sides due to the SEGA mandates turning him into an edgy loner anti-villain. But I would also like a source on this “new Knux mandate”, and am also kinda reluctant to judge because Knuckles taking his duty seriously and becoming more entwined with his heritage are definitely good things in my opinion. Knuckles cares intensely about his island and his job because it’s one of his last connections to his ancestry. He is otherwise completely alone and ignorant of his tribe’s customs and values, and I think that makes for a TON of compelling story opportunities.
  14. Mmm, I still hold that over-description is moot when it comes to these comic books in particular. What you're describing about Ken Penders' work is what I mentioned as the fun/easy parts to write. I've done comic writing myself, and as a writer, many times what you enjoy daydreaming about your characters can be very different from what is actually engaging to an audience. A writer who spends pages just describing how uninteresting characters attending boring parties and talking about nothing important (like in M25YL) is different from a writer who details where all the characters in the scene are and what they're doing. When you write an action-packed scene, you can include all the detail you need and it's up to the artist to convey all the information through their artistic composition. Here's an example from Issue 28, page 17: There is a lot of detail crammed into this one panel that no doubt must have required over-description to some degree. 5 portals, 8 characters, 5 Chaos Emeralds, one portal machine, indications of where they are in the background, an extreme gear, etc. All of these are key to understanding how much happens at once, all in one picture. In this sense, I think something being over-described in script form is irrelevant, because the artists were able to "pick up the slack" so to speak. Their interpretation of the text they were given was able to cram all the relevant details. I think the important part is that the description given by the writer has "meat" to it. There are a whole lot more things that go into writing a compelling narrative that I've learned from school and my own study and research, but my main point is that Comics are a visual medium at the end of the day, and there are a lot more factors than simply over-description, if you ask me.
  15. That point is completely moot with a visual medium like comic books, though. Over-description is a problem, sure, but not when you have a picture to convey a thousand words. Comic books are more than just the writing, it’s certainly a huge factor but you never find paragraphs like the one you used as an example in a comic book. I’m uncertain what you meant to say by using that example.
  16. Well now you’re just trying to start a fight
  17. Good catch! Aggregated Silver character traits include: - Not comfortable around people, misreads and misunderstands them all the time - Easily manipulated - Likes nature of any kind, even the kinds others might dislike - singleminded in a bad way Again, I’m uncertain why him leaning further into the “lovable dummy” angle is a bad thing. If anything he gains a neat distinctive take on Knuckles’ role. He’s a gullible guardian of something he cares a lot about, but he’s got a more unique angle to it. You wouldn’t be able to swap Knuckles and Silver in a room without someone noticing a difference, their thought processes are completely different and I think that’s a good thing.
  18. Hmm, I’m curious. What about it doesn’t track for you? I mean this with no malice and I’m just genuinely puzzled. From how I perceive Silver, there really isn’t anything incongruous about him becoming more of a lovable doofus. In my opinion, there is not much else to Silver’s character as introduced in Sonic 06. Silver is naive or otherwise just not that smart, he commits 100% to one idea until he’s given hard proof of it being false. He is fairly polite to Amy but otherwise seems really baffled and uncomfortable around her, and beyond that, well. Blaze is basically a block of wood in that game so he mostly talks to Mephiles and Shadow. Mephiles constantly manipulates him, while Silver’s interaction with Shadow is fairly cold and professional.
  19. I think it’s also worth noting that the details we’ve been getting from Ian in the Bumblekast surrounding SEGA’s characterization requirements usually backfire pretty bad, so he could be intentionally ambiguous so as to not start another bout of twitter hashtags. Regardless, I’m enjoying seeing the influence of the comics’ (both Archie and IDW) creative team on the games and vice versa. Omega in TSR is very much a hilariously violent character who can never seem to frame anything he says as Not a Threat (“Accept my thanks, or be destroyed!”) which plays masterfully against the rest of the cast imo. Silver’s also a more innocent and singleminded character with an endearing lack of social graces, much like his portrayal in IDW so far. I really enjoy seeing these characters branching out and blooming into their own like that, it’s neat.
  20. That’s a commission from someone else, but even so I LOVE Fleetway Amy so much.
  21. I understand. My apologies for being so forceful about it, even if I come from a place of strong passion and love for the game it doesn’t do any good to vent the frustrations I have in an unproductive way. If we play the same game and have different opinions that’s okay. My struggle with feeling heard is mine, so yeah. Sorry for being an ass like that.
  22. Exactly! I’m very thankful I’m not the only person who feels the game is unfairly dismissed and bashed. I’m always hesitant to share what the game means to me because I find myself guarding and becoming defensive of criticisms that are shallow in my opinion. It’s like that one scene from Lion King where Rafiki has to urge Simba to “look harder.”
  23. The message I’m getting is that it’s the game’s own fault that it was poorly perceived and only the surface level was considered when judging it? It feels unfair to me. If Shadow was misunderstood, then of course it tracks that it was dismissed when it was released. Why should that be held against the game’s own merits?
  24. A new installment of the Sonic Gems Collection with as many games as can be crammed into it and ported well would be amazing. Remakes of the Adventure duology would be welcome as well, because right now the only exposure younger gamers have of sonic games is YouTubers complaining about its glitches and how much it sucks, with the more positive videos very much buried and targeted towards the niche of sonic fans specifically.
  • Create New...

Important Information

You must read and accept our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy to continue using this website. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.