My Sonic 06 Review

[T-Min]

I wrote this half for my blog and half for this place, since my recent playthrough of Sonic 06 has seen me ranting a lot in the status updates. So, if you guys care, here ya go:

-------My Rating System-------

A(-)(+) A top notch experience all the way through. It may not necessarily be perfect, but whatever flaws it does have won’t take you out of it or make it any less worth your time. (Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2)

B(-)(+) A very fun experience bogged down by some significant problems, whether they’re related to the story, gameplay, or both. However, it’s still a good or even great game and worth the price of admission. (Kingdom Hearts: Recoded)

C(-)(+) A mixed bag. Generally fun to some extent and may shine in some areas, but is either too flawed to fully recommend or far too short for its price. Conisder it for a reduced price, at least if you’re a fan of its genre. (Rayman 3D)

D(-)(+) Subpar. It may not be terrible, but it is severely flawed and whatever it does well ultimately fails to save it. Even if you’re a fan of the genre, this is barely a bargain bin purchase. (Sonic Heroes)

F Insipid, disgusting, despicable, and insufferable. It is a scar on the face of human accomplishments that time shall never heal. The best thing we can do is avoid playing it at all costs. It is the only way to prevent its parasitic disease of awfulness from spreading. (Shadow the Hedgehog)

----------------------------------

Hoo boy. Ladies and gents, it's finally time for my review of Sonic the Hedgehog 2006. While Sonic Heroes and Shadow the Hedgehog had already delivered quite a blow to Sonic's reputation, this is the game that made Sonic a laughingstock. While recent titles have seen great improvement - and I do mean great improvement - the public view of the series still hasn't entirely recovered. So, let's go back to the past to see exactly what went so wrong with Sonic's 15th anniversary installment that it caused the entire world to turn against him.

Because the answer is everything.

Good Lord, even looking at the box makes me cringe.

--------------------------------------

*sigh* Well, I suppose I should begin by describing the incomprehensible, horribly written mess this game calls its “story”. Princess Elise is the ruler of a nation known as Soleanna. One day, during a festival celebrating…something…she is attacked by Dr. Eggman, who has somehow become horribly disfigured since the last game. Either that or it’s an incredibly poor attempt at making him fit in with the “realistic” setting of the game …Yeah, it’s the latter.

Why.

So Eggman states that he has come for the Flames of Disaster and the blue Chaos Emerald, which she somehow has kept with her since childhood despite the fact that Sonic and friends have used it on numerous occasions. Speaking of which, Sonic immediately swoops in to save the day. Unfortunately, he is briefly distracted by Eggman’s robots, which causes Elise to get captured immediately after being saved. Then he rescues her again, and they start to develop a…*shudder*…romance. Oh, but things get a bit more complicated when Silver, a hedgehog with psychic powers, steps in. See, Silver comes from a totally not clichéd post-apocalyptic wasteland in which a demon named Iblis has destroyed everything. Silver has been fooled by this shadowy (no pun intended) guy named Mephiles into thinking that Sonic is the “Iblis Trigger”, or the one who would release Iblis. Mephiles himself was trapped in a Scepter of Darkness before he was accidentally released by Shadow, whose form he takes. Oh, and he really hates Shadow, too. And he can time travel for some reason. Whilst fighting Silver, Sonic loses Elise – again – and must go to Eggman’s base to save her – again. When Sonic and friends finally reach Eggman’s base, Eggman uses his latest invention to send them forward through time to Silver’s horrible post-apocalyptic future, where they meet up with Shadow and Rouge, who had been put there by Mephiles. And then more stuff happens.

Our main villain, folks. He makes Maester Seymour look not-ridiculous.

I could write an entire book on the incredibly numerous massive, gaping plot holes that this story falls into, but even without those, this plot is just bad. For one thing, Elise is a human that falls in love with Sonic, who is an animal. At one point, Elise even kisses Sonic. This is horrible. This is despicable. This is disgusting. This is a bad idea. It doesn’t help that the romance receives no development whatsoever and that Elise is a character that makes toast seem interesting. Silver is a similarly awful character. In fact, Silver kind of reminds me of a really bad fancharacter made by a 12-year-old. He’s just as bland as Elise, his design is one of the dumbest I’ve ever seen – ever – and his back story is a pretty blatant ripoff of that of Trunks from Dragon Ball Z. Characterization in general is crap; even our cocky blue hero isn’t interesting or enjoyable in the least. The plot, as a whole, is needlessly convoluted for a game about a talking blue hedgehog, relies on Princess Elise getting captured far too much and features writing that makes Stephanie Meyer’s work look masterful on top of some of the absolute worst voice acting you will ever hear in your life.

And then we get to the aesthetics, and while Sonic 06 sucks less here than in other areas, it’s still pretty sucky. The hub worlds look incredibly bland and the in-game character models are terrible. Their heads look glued on to their bodies and their arms and legs are ridiculously long and thin, which makes them look even more awkward. The game also decided to populate its world with “realistic” humans, though they’re less “realistic” and more “soul-devouring abominations”. The stage environments look okay, I suppose, but up close, a lot of the textures are really blurry. The CGI animated FMV sequences actually look very nice – aside from Princess Elise, who looks like a zombie in pretty much all of them. However, when you watch the other cutscenes, it begins to look like they blew the entire budget on the FMV’s. In-engine cutscenes look simply awful. The characters move like puppets and facial animations look like crap. They hardly show any emotion whatsoever, giving them all this really creepy, zombie-like stare, and lip-syncing wasn’t even attempted. Visual effects, especially “slow motion” moments, are also laughably bad. Oh, and if there’s one aspect of Sonic games whose quality generally remains constant, it’s the soundtrack, but honestly…I don’t even like Sonic 06’s soundtrack that much. I mean, it’s not bad – well, aside from the vocal tracks – but it doesn’t really do much for me either.

And now it’s time to talk about the gameplay, and let me start by saying that this game is broken. Not unpolished, not unrefined, but broken. Scripting is horribly done. If you go into some scripted areas too far to the left or right, you can actually end up dying or getting hurt. Some of them require you to hold the control stick forward, or else you will fall. You can go back to areas featuring scripted events or even jump over any dash pads that initiate scripted events and watch as your character magically defies gravity by walking up loops or walls. Sometimes, characters won’t be able to jump off of rails, you can do light dashes backwards, or the homing attack can stop in mid-air. Collision detection flaws abound, and the physics are simply disgusting. You can stand upright on the sides of things, objects sometimes behave erratically when destroyed and the jump is ridiculously slow and floaty and kills all momentum. At higher speeds, controls become fatally twitchy, making it all too easy to find yourself careening into walls or even a deadly abyss. The camera is bad, as usual, and expect to be spending almost as much time staring at loading screens as you will playing the game. Loading screens occur with remarkable frequency and last a very long time. Simply inexcusable. Oh, and don’t expect a serviceable framerate, either. Of course, none of that is getting into how the game plays. There are three main playable characters – Sonic, Shadow and Silver – and several side characters that you will switch to during gameplay, and all of them suck in their own special little ways. Let’s start with Sonic, whose gameplay is probably the least terrible of the bunch.

Sonic plays similarly to how he did in the Sonic Adventure games. You run to the end of the level, collecting Rings and destroying Eggman’s robots with homing attacks. The difference is that this time Sonic is slow. Despicably, terribly, horribly slow. The only “fast” moments take place when Sonic is being propelled forward by dash pads. However, as I mentioned before, such moments control like crap…that is, when you CAN control Sonic. Sonic’s stages overuse fully scripted sequences to a ludicrous degree, possibly even more so than Sonic Heroes. These sequences don’t even serve any purpose beyond showing off the game’s motion blur effect; they’re still not very fast and they’re completely unspectacular. Sonic Adventure had some similar scripted sequences in its levels, but they were short, fast and looked awesome. Sonic 06’s scripted events are long, slow and boring. Therefore, it’s not okay. Sonic’s stages also feature on-rails sections called Mach Speed Zones where Sonic speeds up a bit, but they, like just about everything else in this game, are terrible. The difficulty is extremely cheap; Sonic loses every one of his Rings upon hitting an obstacle even once, and obstacles tend to come before you can even react to them. You also can’t stop Sonic or turn him around, meaning that if you miss the path forward or get stuck on a wall, you will die. Oh, and don’t forget that the game is generally broken.

The level designs of Sonic’s stages, outside of the Mach Speed Zones anyway, are the main reason why I consider him the least terrible out of the bunch. Of course, that’s not to say that they’re good. Like Sonic Heroes, the game relies on beat-em-up sections far too much, and they aren’t any good at all. See, Sonic 06 suffers from what I like to call “the Rayman 2 fallacy”, in which enemies take several hits to defeat, but combat is essentially just brainless, boring button mashing. Basically, all you have to do is mash the “A” button (or once you get the Bounce Bracelet, the “X” button) over and over again until an enemy is dead. Aside from that, level design is generally bland. While the levels do get points for being large with plenty of alternate routes, the game shoots itself in the foot by making the fastest pathways the most obvious and easiest to take and Sonic is all about getting to the end of the level as fast as possible. Platforming is also bland and blocky and lacks any semblance of challenge, but probably wouldn’t be much fun anyway thanks to a slow and floaty jump. Homing attack chains are also overused, and the homing attack also sucks now because Sonic takes a stupidly long time to recover from it, a decision which downright baffles me.

Oh, but it gets worse. After Sonic’s story, we have Silver’s story. Silver, like I mentioned earlier, has the power of psychokinesis. Though I’m pretty sure the correct term is telekinesis, that’s not what the game calls it, so whatever. Regardless, this translates to the gameplay by allowing Silver to pick up and carry huge objects with his mind and throw them at enemies, or even stun and then catch the enemies themselves. In concept, it’s actually not such a bad idea, but in execution, it’s absolutely insipid. The gameplay is unforgivably slow-paced and gets extremely repetitive and boring very quickly, amounting to nothing more than picking up objects and throwing them at enemies until said enemies are dead. Not to mention that levels can literally drag on for more than ten minutes and there’s hardly even any legitimate platforming, and what little it has is even easier than Sonic’s thanks to his hover ability. Even the primary gameplay mechanic is broken. Hit detection isn’t worth crap and the auto-aim is even more hit or miss than the guns in Shadow the Hedgehog. That’s saying a lot. Objects also tend to brush up against each other when you’re carrying them, meaning that often when you attempt to throw an object, it will just drop to the ground. Just...what?

But even Silver isn’t the worst of what this game has to offer. That would instead be Shadow, whose gameplay might just have you running back to his own revolting semi-spinoff. The gunplay is gone, but it has been replaced by “hand-to-hand combat”. By “hand-to-hand combat”, I mean more mindless button mashing. Shadow’s gameplay gives so much emphasis to the beat-em-up elements that they take priority over almost everything else, and that’s a big part of why his storyline is the worst. Oh, but that’s not the only reason! Shadow’s gameplay still has vehicle segments. However, while they were mostly optional in his self-titled game, in this game they’re mandatory. And they’re even worse, thanks to the fact that each of these vehicles controls like absolute garbage. He also runs even slower than Sonic and recovery time for the homing attack is even longer. Oh, and the homing attack has a much longer range, which results in plenty of cheap deaths when you attempt to use it to make your way across a small gap. Level designs even aside from beat-em-up sections are also horribly bland, even more so than Sonic’s, and, much like Silver’s, his levels drag on for far too long. It’s just…horrid.

Ah, yes, as if three horrible playable characters weren’t enough, there are six “Amigo” characters that you will occasionally switch to. Tails is the absolute slowest character in the game both on the ground and when flying and his only method of attack is a “dummy ring bomb”, for which the hit detection is terrible. The game is so broken that Knuckles and Rouge can hardly get off of walls, much less provide any sort of substantial gameplay experience. Amy’s hammer’s attack range and recovery time are so bad that you’ll probably get hit yourself long before you hit an enemy, and E-123 Omega opens the door to more wonderful button mashing. Blaze the Cat, though, is…actually probably the best-playing character in the game. She’s the fastest – not that that’s saying much – her homing attack has no recovery time whatsoever and she has a double jump. Of course, this being Sonic 06, she still plays like crap. Also, the areas designed around these “Amigo “characters are even more bland and boring than those designed for the main cast.

There are only two more things that deserve mentioning. Bosses in this game are a test of the limits of your patience rather than your skill. They consist of waiting for some chance to attack and repeating this process four times. There’s no challenge involved; merely much boredom and frustration, and some of these bosses take forever to kill. Special mention goes to Iblis Phase 2, which feels less like a boss fight and more like a horrible waiting game. Also, the hub worlds of the game are needlessly large expanses with absolutely nothing of value to do in them. Oh, sure, there are “Town Missions”, but they’re just as boring and frustrating as the rest of the game.

----------------------------------

To call Sonic 2006 a bad game is a severe understatement. Even when you don’t look at it as something that came out of a franchise as beloved as Sonic the Hedgehog, it is quite possibly one of the worst games ever made, period. When you do look at it that way, it’s an insult to the Sonic fanbase, an insult to the Xbox 360 and PS3 consoles, an insult to the gaming population and an insult to mankind as a whole. I doubt I have ever played a game quite as insipid, quite as disgusting, quite as all-around terrible as Sonic the Hedgehog 2006. I truly can’t compliment a single aspect of this game. Please, do yourself a favor and never touch this game. Ever.

So, now that I have finally given all of the bad mainstream Sonic games a proper beatdown, it’s time to move on and forget abominations like this ever existed. As of Sonic Generations, Sonic games are officially awesome again and a far cry from awful games like this. I would call both Sonic Colors and Sonic Generations some of my favorite Sonic games and I would even say that Generations is in my top ten favorite games of all time. Let’s just be thankful things aren’t like this anymore, pray that they stay this way and look toward Sonic’s future with optimism. In the meantime, here’s a fitting song from Shadow the Hedgehog:

Yes, it's cheesy, yes, it's stupid, and yes, it's from a terrible game, but it fits perfectly.

Grade: F

Edited April 4, 2012 by T-Man

[Soniman]

Are you implying that this wonderful game is bad? Because that would totally be a shock to my system.

[Jeffhog]

>implying toast isn't interesting

J'ACCUSE!

[OlenJimi]

did it come out in 2006

[neezTHEhuman]

I still want to play this but I can't find a cheap copy for PS3. Great in depth review by the way. Maybe you could look at the DLC too.

[Lamor]

Great review buuuuuut.... NEVER TURN BACK IS AMAZING SONG!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!!

...

Thought about doing spoken reviews via Youtube?

[T-Min]

Are you implying that this wonderful game is bad? Because that would totally be a shock to my system.

Yes, as a matter of fact, I am.

Problem? :U

Great review buuuuuut.... NEVER TURN BACK IS AMAZING SONG!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!! RAGE!!

Meh, I enjoy it too. =P

Thought about doing spoken reviews via Youtube?

Don't have any software to record footage :/

[Rawpowered]

Good review man. I certainly enjoyed reading it. Though may I make a suggestion? Get a Thesaurus, mainly for finding better words than "bland" and "crap". There are alot of good words in there but those two I spotted alot of.

I used to do reviews for games on a different forum (which I was banned from because one of the mods is completely biased and hates me) and I'd really like to share my work with this forum sometime. Maybe it would finally get me back into the hobby.

[DarkDefeater]

I actually like playing through the game, despite the flaws. Does that make me a bad person?

[Chili Dawg]

I still want to play this but I can't find a cheap copy for PS3. Great in depth review by the way. Maybe you could look at the DLC too.

Have you tried Amazon? I got a PS3 copy for like six bucks last summer.

Can't even be bothered to read the review, sorry. Bitching about 06 isn't even worth anyone's time anymore. Anything that can be said about it has been said a million times already.

[Kuzu]

I actually like playing through the game, despite the flaws. Does that make me a bad person?

Yes.

[Komodin]

Great review as always, mon! Seriously, you explained all of my issues with this game better than I ever cared to!

I actually like playing through the game, despite the flaws. Does that make me a bad person?

Nah, you're okay in my book. At least you acknowledge that it's a very flawed game.

[Rawpowered]

I was going to post the Sonic '06 review I did for a forum I used to go on, but that review was written about 2 years ago. Looking back onto it I don't want anyone to see it now. I tried so hard to be funny and it looks awful. I somehow managed to squeeze in a Stage 3: Profit joke.

[T-Min]

I actually like playing through the game, despite the flaws. Does that make me a bad person?

Nah. You just have low standards :UUUUU

In all seriousness, though, as long as you acknowledge that it's a severely flawed game, it's fine. One's enjoyment of the game is subjective, if nothing else.

I was going to post the Sonic '06 review I did for a forum I used to go on, but that review was written about 2 years ago. Looking back onto it I don't want anyone to see it now. I tried so hard to be funny and it looks awful. I somehow managed to squeeze in a Stage 3: Profit joke.

Ugh, I know that feeling. I took down every review I wrote before 2009 out of shame. :/

[pppp]

All i have to say about this game is this:

My most hated game is still Heavy Rain though.

[KHCast]

Do you like Crisis city or aquatic bases music? By the way i think they did a good job with silver in generations. They actually made him look good. Oh and speaking of generations, after replaying 06 how does playing crisis city in generations feel now?

[ArtFenix]

Er..I thought I'd see something actually interesting and new here.

Looks like I was wrong. Showing so much hatred for SNG is so boring and old.

[Lamor]

I actually like playing through the game, despite the flaws. Does that make me a bad person?

No. You can like whatever you want and everyone who tell you that you're bad person because you like something he/she don't like is a stupid moron.

...

I am looking at you Shadic18..... however if it was a joke then you're okay.

[Ming Ming Hatsune]

Brilliant review, but it's nothing new really. We all knew Sonic 06 is the worst Sonic game ever. Another thing:

...it’s time to move on and forget abominations like this ever existed.

We are trying to, but it's impossible. Sonic '06 will forever be in our hearts and the game will be mentioned here in SSMB at least once every week. The game existed 6 years ago and we are still talking about it. Proof? This thread.

Edited April 5, 2012 by Ming Ming Love

[T-Min]

Do you like Crisis city or aquatic bases music? By the way i think they did a good job with silver in generations. They actually made him look good. Oh and speaking of generations, after replaying 06 how does playing crisis city in generations feel now?

Crisis City's and Aquatic Base's themes are...okay. Like I said, the soundtrack doesn't do much for me. And yeah, I guess Silver looks all right in Generations. I still don't care about the design, but the model is far superior.

Crisis City in Generations is a masterfully designed, legitimately difficult level with fun platforming and short, but sweet scripted events. Crisis City in 06 is quite the opposite.

We are trying to, but it's impossible. Sonic '06 will forever be in our hearts and the game will be mentioned here in SSMB at least once every week. The game existed 6 years ago and we are still talking about it. Proof? This thread.

This is true. What I was trying to say, more or less, is that we shouldn't allow games like this to color our view of the franchise anymore, since the most recent 3-D Sonic games have been legitimately great.

[zI Maleficent]

...it’s time to move on and forget abominations like this ever existed.

Would our collective effort to forget the existence of this game not stand a better chance of success without this topic? For clarification, I am not being an ass, however, writing a review detailing complaints we have all heard before, for a game that is several years old by this point seems somewhat counter-productive to the whole 'forget it ever happened', especially given that posting a topic about the subject brings the game in question directly to our attention.

Good review man. I certainly enjoyed reading it. Though may I make a suggestion? Get a Thesaurus, mainly for finding better words than "bland" and "crap". There are alot of good words in there but those two I spotted alot of.

Indeed, the repeated use of certain descriptive words was unnecessary and became rather tiresome.

This is true. What I was trying to say, more or less, is that we shouldn't allow games like this to color our view of the franchise anymore, since the most recent 3-D Sonic games have been legitimately great.

I'm afraid the damage has already been done. Certain people, and indeed, certain fans, will always use opportunities such as this in order to discredit the direction the series has taken / is taking. Not too long ago, I had to explain at length to a friend of mine that Sonic is actually starting to course-correct, and that the franchise shouldn't simply be killed off. Granted, a single person doesn't constitute entire populations, but that is an example of something fans will have to continue to deal with, even as Sonic seems to be improving.

[Scott]

Brilliant review, but it's nothing new really. We all knew Sonic 06 is the worst Sonic game ever. Another thing:

Purely subjective, I looove the game to bits and haven't experienced anything that hinders my enjoyment other than terrible side missions and horribly realistic humans. Other than that though, it was platforming gold for me. I genuingly got hours of fun out of it. Personally the worst Sonic game to me, isn't even a Sonic game...*cough Tails Adventure cough*

[KingMan]

...it's time to move on and forget abominations like this ever existed.

Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it. Move on, yes, but don't pretend like it never existed. If any good came from Sonic Next Gen, it's, for what it's worth, how not to make a Sonic game, or games in general.

[Rawpowered]

If any good came from Sonic Next Gen, it's, for what it's worth, how not to make a Sonic game, or games in general.

Says The King from the Zelda CDi games.

[Urban Flow]

Purely subjective, I looove the game to bits and haven't experienced anything that hinders my enjoyment other than terrible side missions and horribly realistic humans. Other than that though, it was platforming gold for me. I genuingly got hours of fun out of it. Personally the worst Sonic game to me, isn't even a Sonic game...*cough Tails Adventure cough*