Unrealistic Sonic game ideas!

[Wentos]

You heard me right!

I'm sure most people at one point had an unrealistic idea for a Sonic game. An outlandish idea that would never happen, like a crossover or strange gimmick. Post your idea for a Sonic game that would never happen here! Try to avoid just listing a name, and include some detail if you can.

And before anyone else makes the joke,

My personal unrealistic Sonic game is a Sonic rhythm game. Whether it be a Sonic edition of Guitar Hero or Rock Band, or an entirely new rhythm game built for Sonic, I would love and enjoy every second of it.

Edited July 7, 2012 by Hatsune Miku

[Tornado]

Sequel to Sonic Chronicles.

Y'all mad?

Edited July 7, 2012 by Gilda

[Tori Himemiya]

A real GTA and Sonic crossover.

Obviously this wouldn't happen at all since Sonic wouldn't shoot people.

[Soniman]

Big's Fishing Simulator.

Edited July 7, 2012 by The Noodle

[Urban Flow]

A real GTA and Sonic crossover.

Obviously this wouldn't happen at all since Sonic wouldn't shoot people.

It could happen with Shadow though =P

[Diogenes]

Full 3D, classic inspired gameplay. Nearly the entire cast is playable, with most characters joining you as you progress the story, and ones that can't be fit into the story being unlockable afterwards. Everyone shares the same core gameplay, but they each have a few unique abilities as well. Something kind of like Brawl's Subspace Emissary, only all Sonic.

A JRPG with a battle system somewhat similar to Paper Mario, but taking place on a pair of 3x3 grids similar to the Mega Man Battle Network games. Fighting well would have more to do with understanding how to control the battle and turn it to your advantage rather than straight damage. For example, say there are flying enemies that can only be hit by certain attacks (the same way Paper Mario has flying enemies that you can jump on but you can't use your hammer on). And say Sonic has an axe kick that normally just does mediocre damage, but against flying enemies it knocks them to the ground, maybe stuns them and/or does extra damage. And there's a whole bunch of special interactions like that, with different attacks and different (kinds of) enemies.

[novelty]

Paper Sonic 3DS.

Yeah, I went there.

[Wentos]

I think some of you might be getting the wrong idea about this topic. Be sure to read the description for maximum discussion value!

[Wittymations]

A real Sonic and Mario cannon, main-series, platformer. Though it's desired, and is wanted, it just won't happen.

[Komodin]

Hm, how about this:

A Sonic Dating Sim with Elise, Amy, Blaze, Rouge, Cream, Shadow and Eggman as potential SO's.

Edited July 7, 2012 by Komodin

[Sami]

How about you change the title to "Sonic games you would really want" or something?

I'd be totally down for a Sonic rhythm game, especially if it meant it gave us a final boss as awesomely silly as this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAf4-Z1jxYw

Seriously. Give me Breakdancing Eggman and I'll buy it twice.

[Wittymations]

Though, as far as a not-so-joky Sonic game. I had a similar idea of a Sonic game. One that didn't really go guitar heroes, but still focused on music.

My idea would have Eggman make about four or five different bots. Each colored different and represented a different form of music and had a certain genre-stereotype attitude:

Blue: Blues (dur...): Soft, but deep spoken. Says things like "Daddy-o"

Black: Metal (or hard rock): A bit more chaotic, considerably eviler than the rest.

Green (or red): Rap: Comic relief in a lot of areas, but still very dangerous, speaks some gangsta-esqueness, but not overdone.

Pink: Pop, cheerful and dangerous. Cheerleaderish attitude.

Gull-grey: Country: Has a tough cowboy-esque (also older, attitude wise), argues with a few of the other bots.

Eggman, himself, would cover techno, in the final battle.

In this game, I'd like the boss battles, especially, to be reliant on music. For instance, the beats that play in the background is synced to when a boss will attack you.and you have to jump, dodge, and attack with it.

I'd like each zone to fit the genre type you're chasing. Pop could easily hit the beach areas, rap more urban, and metal more hell-like, or industrialist. Perhaps blues could be more of jazzy nightclub, and country to be open rural fields?

As far as what could be a nice music gimmick, maybe if you hit and run well to the background music in each zone, you could build up something? Like, for a "Sync Bar" and unleash specail attacks? Just a random idea.

[CrownSlayers Shadow]

Anything with Hyper Sonic in it.

[Old dead account]

A new game that actually builds on the classics rather than do a slanderous misrepresentation of them that claims to be better because of ceiling running. 2D or 3D for that matter.

Also

[Wentos]

A new game that actually builds on the classics rather than do a slanderous misrepresentation of them that claims to be better because of ceiling running. 2D or 3D for that matter.

Also

My eyes!

[Wittymations]

Also

A lot of people would buy this hoping for porn.

[SIXTH-RATE SOMA]

Sonic Storybook: Sonic the Hedgehog & The Laws of Robotics

Impossible? Yes. Awesome/So Bad It's Good? We can only hope.

[Rally the Cheetah]

A game where Nack the Weasel/ Fang the Sniper is a mid boss and Dr. Eggman gets turned into a Walrus at the end for some reason...

[Wentos]

A game where Nack the Weasel/ Fang the Sniper is a mid boss and Dr. Eggman gets turned into a Walrus at the end for some reason...

Well, he is the Eggman.

/The Beatles

Edited July 7, 2012 by Hatsune Miku

[Phos]

Sonic Storybook: Sonic the Hedgehog & The Laws of Robotics

Impossible? Yes. Awesome/So Bad It's Good? We can only hope.

Oh, Storybook games are a gold mine, with such possibilities as "Dark Gaia Shrugged" and "Sonic on the Western Front" and "Sonic and the Brave New World".

[Wittymations]

Oh, Storybook games are a gold mine, with such possibilities as "Dark Gaia Shrugged" and "Sonic on the Western Front" and "Sonic and the Brave New World".

My choice:

To Spindash a Mockingbird

[Chili Dawg]

I still wanna see Sonic and The Bible happen.

"Hey, Jesus, how about a race across this body of water?"

[Lamor]

Sequel to Sonic Unleashed. I know it won't happen but I'd love to see new places they could create.

[Old dead account]

I still wanna see Sonic and The Bible happen.

"Hey, Jesus, how about a race across this body of water?"

And thus starting the greatest video game controversy in history and claiming that Sega is the devil.

[batson]

A game where Vector appears and doesn't sound like Barney Gumble. Oh how i miss his Heroes voice-actor.

On a more serious note, i'd love to see a really story-heavy Sonic game, like, im talking Metal Gear Solid levels of emphasis on a complex story with complex characters.