Jump to content
Dejimon11

IDW's Sonic the Hedgehog

Recommended Posts

Well, I hope no one is  tired of "Sonic team-up and smashes Badnik" routine. But hey, new Whisper is here. Or as I like to call her "Overwatch is popular "

Spoiler

Maybe I'm jumping to conclusion but she really feels like new character to Overwatch, just with Sonic Forced theme. Anyway, she used 5 wisp (3 from Forces) but she clearly has at least 6 containers? Is the last one some kind of "last resort weapon"? Void perhaps? It also implied that she has some history with Eggman, that's nice.

So overall she leaves a nice impression, with Flynn as always cheekily leaving more for later. Now let's ship her with Tangle just because. Sorry

Silver is written well, but I read Archie, this isn't anything new to me. Interesting that Sega allows Flynn to mess around with his future. Mentioning of water and metallic plants obviously makes me think of Little Planet, perhaps Chaos. That's neat.

Artwork is Stanely, it's obviously good. So all that cool artwork, seeding plot-points for the future and new characters almost make you ignore that story is "smashing badniks" again.. Almost. Yeah, E-100 are back, I guess that's improvement , the same way standing on thick carpet makes me look taller. It's still can fodder for Sonic. They didn't even tried to came up with new design , that's lazy (admittedly something something bolted to the floor can't  be K.O. in a second by Silver).
Also, do you think they will repeat numbers from Archie? Not a big deal, but I would prefer if they jumped forward. Only nerds will notice and nerds probably read Archie and actually appreciate this.

And finally cliffhanger, but we all saw this coming. I'm just disappointed that Metal got Master Emerald with such ease. Again, that makes Knuckles looks a bit dumb for not taking it with him. Oh well, knowing Flynn they will point that out in next issue.

So overall comic continues being "nice, cool, kinda neat". Everything is pretty good, as long as you're willing to live with simple story.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I kind will always have weird issues with comic book silver. And any other interpretation of silver at this point not in a game? It feels like silver never really got a defined personality. So every comic book interpretation just seems like ... winging it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Shadowlax said:

I kind will always have weird issues with comic book silver. And any other interpretation of silver at this point not in a game? It feels like silver never really got a defined personality. So every comic book interpretation just seems like ... winging it

IDK, even if it's "winging", it's fairly consistent between versions, even fan arts.

In short he's a hero, but not as "cool" as Shadow or Sonic. A bit of dork, but he makes up for it in "a strong sense of justice".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm sure I'm running this complaint into the ground at this point, but I really am tired of every issue jumping around just to introduce more characters and have meaningless fight scenes. Whisper may or may not end up being an interesting character but I feel like there's no chance of knowing for a year or two because they'll just jump to some other character's business next issue. And what even got accomplished here? They found out information they were too late to act on and would find out basically 30 seconds later anyway.

Spoiler

Ae8oNdu.png

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Dorky Silver" is when he's at his best imo. Gives the guy some humility without turning him into a complete joke. Him trying his hardest to be friendly but being a bit awkward just makes him endearing compared to when he was just another stiff imo. I like the contrast between Silver trying to be more of a proper hero and Sonic's more laidback approach to everything. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm actually going to be that guy and say I'm not too fond of this SIlver, mostly because he comes off a bit redundant when Tangle already somewhat embodies his personality. Both are dorky, both have some sort of idolization/fanboyism/crush(????) on a character (Tangle to Blaze and maybe Sonic, Silver to Whisper). The issue itself being yet another "Sonic gets to the place, someone saves him, they talk a little bit, they fight some big baddie and then they talk a little bit more about overarching plot" doesn't help either. I don't mind Silver being a little bit dorky, but I feel like in this issue Ian went a bit overboard with dorkiness.

At least Whisper is cute. Also Silver has the objectively best panel in the whole series:

Spoiler

image.jpg

and you're wrong if you say otherwise /s

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok, here's my summarized thoughts on issue #8:

I 👏 need 👏 more 👏 Whisper 👏

Spoiler

Also Metal is turning Angel Island into Eggmanland 2.0 or something, that could lead into something, but...

I 👏 need 👏 more 👏 Whisper 👏

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, Dash Speed said:

 

  Hide contents

 Wisper is yet another misguided Cream type of girl that literally acts like a Cream Type, she wasn't worth the panel space at all, plus the cutesy stuff with her and Silver in the end is just cringe  [/spolier]

WTF
 

Spoiler

 

Whisper is a Cream type? You're saying she acts like Cream? You're seriously comparing the skittishly shy assassin with a vendetta against Eggman to the dainty, pacifist, biggest social butterfly in the series who would break bread with her enemies mid battle?

The similarities between the two are pretty far off to go claim they were built from the same mold. Personality wise they couldn't be farther apart.

 

 

1 hour ago, Bobnik said:

I'm actually going to be that guy and say I'm not too fond of this SIlver, mostly because he comes off a bit redundant when Tangle already somewhat embodies his personality. Both are dorky, both have some sort of idolization/fanboyism/crush(????) on a character (Tangle to Blaze and maybe Sonic, Silver to Whisper)

 

 

I think what sets them apart will be Silvers penchant for leadership. While Tangle will find it difficult to climb her way out of the trope, Silver can easily fall back into his Flynn time-tested pattern of recruitment and pick up where he left off building a Squad. Between the Secret Freedom Fighters and the Silver Age crew, Flynn has made Silver into a nexus of team-building, and the ground work for Whisper to be his next recruit appears to already be in motion.

If Silver continues to progress as I expect him too, than his redundancies with Tangle will fix themselves as Silver will quickly evolve past his dorky side character into a Leader with some quirks - a role which the series is actually quite deprived off.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Aaah, I really liked this issue, but it's already obvious why~! xD
Silver's personality is hilariously goofy and I love it. The reasoning behind why he's so attached to Whisper is pretty good. I dig it.

Also, I don't really see Silver's fanboying over Whisper as a "crush;" more like he admires her for being able to do what he... can't (?) on his own? Is that the right way to put it? Anyway, I definitely see them becoming a team, and maybe they'll form that brother-sister relationship that he and Blaze were originally portrayed to have. Oh, and I really like Whisper! I like her bond with the wisps, and I'm curious to see what Ian plans on bringing to the table with her and her situation. Her design is also really nice to look at. Great use of color!

Anyway, this issue really delivered for me. I've been waiting for this one for a while, and I'm glad it met my expectations! ^^ Excited for more, of course!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, VEDJ-F said:

But Silver already is that in the games, he doesn't really need to grow into it there. 

Does he? He's just as open to teamwork as the next guy but outside of some Dialog in Forces he's never really stepped up as a leader. He was super dependent on Blaze in 06, Took notes form Espio in Rivals and fell in line during his limited screen-time in Generations.

Silver's leadership in the games pales to what Ian built him up to be in the back end of the Archie comics. Silver lead the Secret FFs (which had some big personalities) and carved up his SIlver Age posse from scratch. SegaSilver hardly has that same motivation - he just rolls with the punches as they come like most of the cast.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, BlossomHaze said:

Aaah, I really liked this issue, but it's already obvious why~! xD
Silver's personality is hilariously goofy and I love it. The reasoning behind why he's so attached to Whisper is pretty good. I dig it.

Also, I don't really see Silver's fanboying over Whisper as a "crush;" more like he admires her for being able to do what he... can't (?) on his own? Is that the right way to put it? Anyway, I definitely see them becoming a team, and maybe they'll form that brother-sister relationship that he and Blaze were originally portrayed to have. Oh, and I really like Whisper! I like her bond with the wisps, and I'm curious to see what Ian plans on bringing to the table with her and her situation. Her design is also really nice to look at. Great use of color!

Anyway, this issue really delivered for me. I've been waiting for this one for a while, and I'm glad it met my expectations! ^^ Excited for more, of course!

I agree with that. Fandoms literally  these days like to overreach on things just to ship characters.  just cause someone does something epic like blowing a battleship up aka blaze or whisper with silver. A character saying wow that was just amazing wow. You did an amazing job! In no form means that person has a crush. Otherwise us have a crush on every person I've ever played with in overwatch from a good potg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just a theory about the hinted past of Whisper

Spoiler

Maybe it's not something that happens to her, but more something related to her wisp friends : I think that the last wisp is a nega-wisp (violet or purple), and that she can't let him out because it would be dangerous/rabbid, or something like that ? And that that's also why she doesn't like Eggman, because she care about these creatures, and think that the transformation caused by Hyper-Go-On energy extraction was horrible ?

It's just a silly theory, though :V

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, Kazhnuz said:

Just a theory about the hinted past of Whisper

  Reveal hidden contents

Maybe it's not something that happens to her, but more something related to her wisp friends : I think that the last wisp is a nega-wisp (violet or purple), and that she can't let him out because it would be dangerous/rabbid, or something like that ? And that that's also why she doesn't like Eggman, because she care about these creatures, and think that the transformation caused by Hyper-Go-On energy extraction was horrible ?

It's just a silly theory, though :V

 

I think this is pretty solid, actually. I imagine hee beef with eggman is tied to the wisps some kind of way

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 minutes ago, Wraith said:

I think this is pretty solid, actually. I imagine hee beef with eggman is tied to the wisps some kind of way

I think none of them are nega, I looked their pictures on the wikia.

Also, all these wisps are the same ones from issue 9 cover.

Evan Stanley actualluy makes the wisps cute and appealing, someone no other artist did for me, I might like them as much as the chao now. I hope Tracy Yardley renders them this appealing in issue 9 too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
55 minutes ago, MetalSkulkBane said:

Quick question, is there any artist here?

Cause I need a fan art of Whisper and her Wisp friends having punch up with Eclipse and his Wisp babies.

I need it. NOW. Shipping picture will be acceptable too. I'm flexible.

I actually would love to do this!!!

And I agree with the theory that something happened to the Wisps, and that's why she's angry. I'm sure we'll find out soon!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, Marco9966 said:

I think none of them are nega, I looked their pictures on the wikia.

We have seen 5 of her 6 wisp (there is one where the wisp doesn't come out), and that's the same 5 that are in the cover. What I'm saying is that the sixth is a Nega-Wisp (I think a Purple one)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This one was a nice lead in issue, as expected. 

I enjoyed the issue overall. The majority of the beginning through the middle was the best of the issue's content. Ian's character work continues to be the best part about his writing and I could read the dialogue between these guys practically forever. It's incredible how well "Adorkable Silver" works here. I'm glad he's endeared himself to me as a character I can grow to outright love nowadays. He and I had a rocky start but now, every time I see him in action, he goes up a few notches for me, which is great. The line "I'm a big fan" is heart-meltingly cute.

Whisper had a different personality than I was expecting based on her concept art. That's good because I think I may have found myself more interested in her than Tangle. Tangle was roughly what I expected personality wise, if not a few things being a tad surprising to the point where I found her charming but I wasn't left itching for me like I am here. I do have a genuine interest in seeing where this character ends up.

Of course, the issue ends with another fight scene and unlike Issue 7 where it got to breathe and be the highlight because of excellent choreography and artistry, this one falls in line with a lot of the usual stuff. A bunch of bouncy balls flying all over the place, explosions, and movement that's hard to pinpoint at times. If anything stuff like this continues to stand as  proof to me that Ian would be excellent at writing for the games. The cutscene would start when Sonic meets Silver. They'd run through the level. Another cutscene would happen when they're discussing and then meeting Whisper. Then they'd break into the room and have their Boss Battle against E-107. 

It's perfect for that but in a comic, it's admittedly very redundant. This has been Ian's style of writing for a long while though and it's mostly a lot more formulaic and noticeable this go around here at Issue 8 of this entirely new comic where things are still very much building to its first climax. 

Good issue. I enjoyed the characterization. The fighting not so much but it wasn't the majority of the issue and what it accomplished overall was ultimately satisfying on the whole. I'm eager to see the first big battle go down. 

Still, I gotta say, its a shame this man isn't writing for the games. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, MetalSkulkBane said:

IDK, even if it's "winging", it's fairly consistent between versions, even fan arts.

In short he's a hero, but not as "cool" as Shadow or Sonic. A bit of dork, but he makes up for it in "a strong sense of justice".

I don't think its consistent between versions, and its not consistent within fan art. It is consistent with the comic book, which make sense because the games never... really gave him a personality. I'm not really angry or anything, I don't really care about silver too much to get miffed over this, and sonic forces made silver look way worse than he did here. Its just like silver will always be weird to me, because every personality he has in this book is basically a temp personality untill sega does something with him

Heck I would argue that " a bit of a dork " isn't really a personality at all and he still kind of lacks it. Like with everyone else I can make arguments they did right by them or wrong by them. But with him... he just kinda exists

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, StaticMania said:

It's kinda hard for Whisper to leave much impression...but she's cute, so there's that.

Why is Theta basically Zeta but better?

I know, right?

22 hours ago, Dash Speed said:

 

  Hide contents

Wisper is yet another misguided Cream type of girl that literally acts like a Cream Type, she wasn't worth the panel space at all, plus the cutesy stuff with her and Silver in the end is just cringe  [/spolier]

I don't know if I can stomach more of Ian's stuff.

Uh, excuse you?

21 hours ago, Razule said:

So much for..

  Hide contents

.."bright skies and everyone's got a smile", Silver's future is just always ruined now, dang. Hey, if all organic life was destroyed, how's Silver's still alive? Guess time-travelling makes him immune to the Grandfather Clause. His family must have been erased ten times over, at some point, what's even the point of going back to save the world if everyone you know ceases to be anyway? Or maybe all life only disappeared conveniently just after Silver was born. Huh.

 

 

 

Spoiler

I remember Preboot once proposed the idea of him being a walking paradox/anomaly where time is concerned, so maybe that's how it works.

17 hours ago, Silent Jack said:

 

  Hide contents

It's more in line with issue 4's formula, but it's also a transition to next arc. Silver is written wonderfully, I noticed his social background too, in opposition with Whisper, which is a great idea, in some way she is a blend of Cream and Blaze, shy but kind, a warrior that fights with little aliens. Tangle is also great in "gameplay" idea and she's very unique, while Whisper is a character based on the Avatar but her personality seems intriguing and apparently Eggman did something to her. We'll find out eventually. In fact I think I prefer Whisper to Tangle personality-wise, Tangle was just a Sonic light basically. Whisper shines both in personality and gameplay, I love the upgraded wispon, plus potentially some backstory.

 

She's an easy improvement over Tangle, if you ask me.

16 hours ago, MetalSkulkBane said:

 But hey, new Whisper is here. Or as I like to call her "Overwatch is popular "

  Hide contents

Maybe I'm jumping to conclusion but she really feels like new character to Overwatch, just with Sonic Forced theme. Anyway, she used 5 wisp (3 from Forces) but she clearly has at least 6 containers? Is the last one some kind of "last resort weapon"? Void perhaps? It also implied that she has some history with Eggman, that's nice.

So overall she leaves a nice impression, with Flynn as always cheekily leaving more for later. Now let's ship her with Tangle just because. Sorry

 

 

 

12 hours ago, SBR2 said:

I enjoyed it. I like how Silver was fanboying over Whisper and I also really dig how Whisper is being used to develop more about the War and Eggman's control during Forces. I can't wait to find out more about her.

Nice to finally have some long-term stuff to explore.

 

11 hours ago, VEDJ-F said:

But Silver already is that in the games, he doesn't really need to grow into it there. 

I guess the problem is that he isn't really in games to/that really showcase that.

11 hours ago, Sega DogTagz said:

WTF
 

  Hide contents

 

Whisper is a Cream type? You're saying she acts like Cream? You're seriously comparing the skittishly shy assassin with a vendetta against Eggman to the dainty, pacifist, biggest social butterfly in the series who would break bread with her enemies mid battle?

The similarities between the two are pretty far off to go claim they were built from the same mold. Personality wise they couldn't be farther apart.

 

 

 

 

I wouldn't say social butterfly, per say, but she's definitely hospitable.

12 hours ago, Bobnik said:

I'm actually going to be that guy and say I'm not too fond of this SIlver, mostly because he comes off a bit redundant when Tangle already somewhat embodies his personality. Both are dorky, both have some sort of idolization/fanboyism/crush(????) on a character (Tangle to Blaze and maybe Sonic, Silver to Whisper).  I don't mind Silver being a little bit dorky, but I feel like in this issue Ian went a bit overboard with dorkiness.

 

Does he? 

Idk, the only real character trait I've seen attributed to Tangle proper is "goofball." Well that and apparently Audience Surrogate, which means little at the moment.

Silver here(and Whisper for that matter) has more definition to him.

8 hours ago, MetalSkulkBane said:

Quick question, is there any artist here?

Cause I need a fan art of Whisper and her Wisp friends having punch up with Eclipse and his Wisp babies.

I need it. NOW. Shipping picture will be acceptable too. I'm flexible.

That's what I thinking of when I saw they could leave their canisters willingly and while Whisper was hiding, no less.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

You must read and accept our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy to continue using this website. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.